Facial Recognition Is Accurate, if You’re a White Guy – The New York Times

By | febbraio 13, 2018

Facial Recognition Is Accurate, if You’re a White Guy – The New York Times

Link articolo originale

Archivio di tutti i clip:
clips.quintarelli.it
(Notebook di Evernote).

Facial Recognition Is Accurate, if You’re a White Guy

The new study also raises broader questions of fairness and accountability in artificial intelligence at a time when investment in and adoption of the technology is racing ahead.
Today, facial recognition software is being deployed by companies in various ways, including to help target product pitches based on social media profile pictures. But companies are also experimenting with face identification and other A.I. technology as an ingredient in automated decisions with higher stakes like hiring and lending.
Researchers at the Georgetown Law School estimated that 117 million American adults are in face recognition networks used by law enforcement — and that African Americans were most likely to be singled out, because they were disproportionately represented in mug-shot databases.
Facial recognition technology is lightly regulated so far.
“This is the right time to be addressing how these A.I. systems work and where they fail — to make them socially accountable,” said Suresh Venkatasubramanian, a professor of computer science at the University of Utah.
Until now, there was anecdotal evidence of computer vision miscues, and occasionally in ways that suggested discrimination. In 2015, for example, Google had to apologize after its image-recognition photo app initially labeled African Americans as “gorillas.”
Sorelle Friedler, a computer scientist at Haverford College and a reviewing editor on Ms. Buolamwini’s research paper, said experts had long suspected that facial recognition software performed differently on different populations.
“But this is the first work I’m aware of that shows that empirically,” Ms. Friedler said.
Ms. Buolamwini, a young African-American computer scientist, experienced the bias of facial recognition firsthand. When she was an undergraduate at the Georgia Institute of Technology, programs would work well on her white friends, she said, but not recognize her face at all. She figured it was a flaw that would surely be fixed before long.

Photo

Joy Buolamwini, a researcher at the M.I.T. Media Lab, has emerged as an advocate in the new field of “algorithmic accountability.” Credit Tony Luong for The New York Times

But a few years later, after joining the M.I.T. Media Lab, she ran into the missing-face problem again. Only when she put on a white mask did the software recognize hers as a face.
By then, face recognition software was increasingly moving out of the lab and into the mainstream.
“O.K., this is serious,” she recalled deciding then. “Time to do something.”
So she turned her attention to fighting the bias built into digital technology. Now 28 and a doctoral student, after studying as a Rhodes scholar and a Fulbright fellow, she is an advocate in the new field of “algorithmic accountability,” which seeks to make automated decisions more transparent, explainable and fair.
Her short TED Talk on coded bias has been viewed more than 940,000 times, and she founded the Algorithmic Justice League, a project to raise awareness of the issue.
In her newly published paper, which will be presented at a conference this month, Ms. Buolamwini studied the performance of three leading face recognition systems — by Microsoft, IBM and Megvii of China — by classifying how well they could guess the gender of people with different skin tones. These companies were selected because they offered gender classification features in their facial analysis software — and their code was publicly available for testing.
She found them all wanting.
To test the commercial systems, Ms. Buolamwini built a data set of 1,270 faces, using faces of lawmakers from countries with a high percentage of women in office. The sources included three African nations with predominantly dark-skinned populations, and three Nordic countries with mainly light-skinned residents.
The African and Nordic faces were scored according to a six-point labeling system used by dermatologists to classify skin types. The medical classifications were determined to be more objective and precise than race.
Then, each company’s software was tested on the curated data, crafted for gender balance and a range of skin tones. The results varied somewhat. Microsoft’s error rate for darker-skinned women was 21 percent, while IBM’s and Megvii’s rates were nearly 35 percent. They all had error rates below 1 percent for light-skinned males.
Ms. Buolamwini shared the research results with each of the companies. IBM said in a statement to her that the company had steadily improved its facial analysis software and was “deeply committed” to “unbiased” and “transparent” services. This month, the company said, it will roll out an improved service with a nearly 10-fold increase in accuracy on darker-skinned women.
Microsoft said that it had “already taken steps to improve the accuracy of our facial recognition technology” and that it was investing in research “to recognize, understand and remove bias.”
Ms. Buolamwini’s co-author on her paper is Timnit Gebru, who described her role as an adviser. Ms. Gebru is a scientist at Microsoft Research, working on its Fairness Accountability Transparency and Ethics in A.I. group.

Photo

Timnit Gebru, a scientist at Microsoft Research, was a co-author of the paper that studied facial recognition software. Credit Cody O’Loughlin for The New York Times

Megvii, whose Face++ software is widely used for identification in online payment and ride-sharing services in China, did not reply to several requests for comment, Ms. Buolamwini said.
Ms. Buolamwini is releasing her data set for others to build upon. She describes her research as “a starting point, very much a first step” toward solutions.
Ms. Buolamwini is taking further steps in the technical community and beyond. She is working with the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, a large professional organization in computing, to set up a group to create standards for accountability and transparency in facial analysis software.
She meets regularly with other academics, public policy groups and philanthropies that are concerned about the impact of artificial intelligence. Darren Walker, president of the Ford Foundation, said that the new technology could be a “platform for opportunity,” but that it would not happen if it replicated and amplified bias and discrimination of the past.
“There is a battle going on for fairness, inclusion and justice in the digital world,” Mr. Walker said.
Part of the challenge, scientists say, is that there is so little diversity within the A.I. community.
“We’d have a lot more introspection and accountability in the field of A.I. if we had more people like Joy,” said Cathy O’Neil, a data scientist and author of “Weapons of Math Destruction.”
Technology, Ms. Buolamwini said, should be more attuned to the people who use it and the people it’s used on.
“You can’t have ethical A.I. that’s not inclusive,” she said. “And whoever is creating the technology is setting the standards.”

Correction: February 11, 2018
Because of an editing error, an earlier version of the grid of photos misstated the number of photos in the data sets for the first two rows. The top row, of lighter-skinned males, was in a set of 385 photos, not 296; the second row, lighter-skinned females, was in a set of 296 photos, not 385.

Follow Steve Lohr on Twitter @SteveLohr

A version of this article appears in print on February 12, 2018, on Page B1 of the New York edition with the headline: Facial Recognition Works Best If You’re a White Guy. Order Reprints Today’s PaperSubscribe

Continue reading the main story

The post Facial Recognition Is Accurate, if You’re a White Guy – The New York Times appeared first on Quinta’s weblog.

Source: Stefano quintarelli- Blog

344 thoughts on “Facial Recognition Is Accurate, if You’re a White Guy – The New York Times

  1. Pingback: wireless buzzer system for classroom

  2. Pingback: replacement quartz clock movements

  3. Pingback: click the following post

  4. Pingback: Montana Fire Pits

  5. Pingback: Warming trends fire pit

  6. Pingback: propane fire pit burner

  7. Pingback: clock mechanism kit

  8. Pingback: Visit Now

  9. Pingback: wireless pa system

  10. Pingback: school public address system

  11. Pingback: Visit Now

  12. Pingback: Fire pit natural gas burner

  13. Pingback: Montana Firepit

  14. Pingback: Montana Fire Pits

  15. Pingback: Logs for gas fire pit

  16. Pingback: Montana Fire Pits

  17. Pingback: diy gas fire pit burner

  18. Pingback: outdoor fire pit logs

  19. Pingback: fire pit tray

  20. Pingback: Fire pit natural gas burner

  21. Pingback: fire pit bowls

  22. Pingback: warming trends dealers

  23. Pingback: outdoor fire pit logs

  24. Pingback: Warming trends fire pit kit

  25. Pingback: warming trends fire pit burners

  26. Pingback: warming trends gas burners

  27. Pingback: auto accident injury lawyer

  28. Pingback: auto accident injury lawyer

  29. Pingback: Warming trends fire pit

  30. Pingback: omaha law firms

  31. Pingback: truck accident lawyer

  32. Pingback: Omaha truck accident attorney

  33. Pingback: best truck accident attorney

  34. Pingback: gas fire pits outdoor

  35. Pingback: motorcycle accident lawyer

  36. Pingback: truck accident law firm

  37. Pingback: truck wreck lawyer

  38. Pingback: automobile injury attorney

  39. Pingback: denver basements

  40. Pingback: basement finish denver co

  41. Pingback: colorado basement finishing cost

  42. Pingback: basement finishing denver co

  43. Pingback: basement finishing colorado

  44. Pingback: basement finishing colorado

  45. Pingback: basements and beyond denver reviews

  46. Pingback: denver basement finishing cost

  47. Pingback: essential oil for depression

  48. Pingback: basementology

  49. Pingback: how to use essential oils for anxiety

  50. Pingback: best essential oils for stress and anxiety

  51. Pingback: basements and beyond denver reviews

  52. Pingback: denver basements

  53. Pingback: what essential oils are good for depression

  54. Pingback: what essential oil is good for anxiety

  55. Pingback: Affordable Basement Finishing

  56. Pingback: how to ease anxiety

  57. Pingback: colorado basement finishing cost

  58. Pingback: basement remodel denver

  59. Pingback: oils for anxiety

  60. Pingback: best essential oils for depression

  61. Pingback: Visit Today

  62. Pingback: Click This

  63. Pingback: best essential oils for anxiety

  64. Pingback: basement remodeling denver co

  65. Pingback: Get Access

  66. Pingback: denver basement remodel

  67. Pingback: Affordable Basement Finishing Co

  68. Pingback: relaxing essential oils

  69. Pingback: essential oil recipes for anxiety

  70. Pingback: diy clock kit

  71. Pingback: Visit Today

  72. Pingback: relieve anxiety

  73. Pingback: diy clock kit

  74. Pingback: where to buy quartz clock movements

  75. Pingback: Aroma Sense Anxiety Relief

  76. Pingback: essential oils for depression

  77. Pingback: clock parts

  78. Pingback: how to use essential oils for anxiety

  79. Pingback: clock movement kit

  80. Pingback: clock parts

  81. Pingback: stress relief essential oil blend

  82. Pingback: Learn More

  83. Pingback: essential oil for stress

  84. Pingback: Aroma Sense

  85. Pingback: wholesale clock movement kits

  86. Pingback: oils for anxiety

  87. Pingback: anxiety cures

  88. Pingback: diy clock kit

  89. Pingback: clock kits

  90. Pingback: Aroma Sense

  91. Pingback: diy clock kit

  92. Pingback: clock replacement parts

  93. Pingback: electric clock movements

  94. Pingback: best essential oils for depression

  95. Pingback: best quality quartz clock movements

  96. Pingback: clock dials

  97. Pingback: essential oil for anxiety attack

  98. Pingback: clock parts

  99. Pingback: clock parts

  100. Pingback: battery operated quartz clock movements

  101. Pingback: read more

  102. Pingback: clock kits

  103. Pingback: clock movement kit

  104. Pingback: Aroma Sense Essential Oils

  105. Pingback: Aroma Sense Anxiety Relief

  106. Pingback: clock Kit

  107. Pingback: clock Kit

  108. Pingback: clock movement kit

  109. Pingback: clock mechanism kit

  110. Pingback: clock parts

  111. Pingback: clock kits

  112. Pingback: how to ease anxiety

  113. Pingback: clock movement kit

  114. Pingback: clockkits

  115. Pingback: clock kit

  116. Pingback: best essential oils for stress and anxiety

  117. Pingback: clock movements

  118. Pingback: clock kits

  119. Pingback: clock dials

  120. Pingback: best quality quartz clock movements

  121. Pingback: clock inserts

  122. Pingback: essential oil for anxiety attack

  123. Pingback: clock hands

  124. Pingback: clock part

  125. Pingback: see now

  126. Pingback: clock kits

  127. Pingback: clock parts

  128. Pingback: read more here

  129. Pingback: battery operated quartz clock movements

  130. Pingback: building erectors

  131. Pingback: metal building erectors

  132. Pingback: metal church buildings

  133. Pingback: design build contractors

  134. Pingback: Additional Information

  135. Pingback: erectors

  136. Pingback: erectors

  137. Pingback: tenant improvement contractor

  138. Pingback: browse these sites

  139. Pingback: tenant improvements construction

  140. Pingback: metal church buildings contractor

  141. Pingback: steel building erectors

  142. Pingback: steel building contractors

  143. Pingback: additional resource

  144. Pingback: metal church buildings

  145. Pingback: design builder

  146. Pingback: browse these experts

  147. Pingback: tenant improvement contractor

  148. Pingback: Industrial Contractors

  149. Pingback: metal building erection

  150. Pingback: design build firms

  151. Pingback: design build firms

  152. Pingback: article sources

  153. Pingback: building erectors

  154. Pingback: Construction Management

  155. Pingback: metal building contractors

  156. Pingback: tenant improvements construction

  157. Pingback: metal building erectors

  158. Pingback: industrial construction services

  159. Pingback: general contractor

  160. Pingback: general contractor services

  161. Pingback: steel building erector

  162. Pingback: design build general contractor

  163. Pingback: metal building contractors

  164. Pingback: browse these sites

  165. Pingback: battery operated quartz clock movements

  166. Pingback: metal building contractors

  167. Pingback: check the url

  168. Pingback: facility builder

  169. Pingback: Tenant Improvement

  170. Pingback: battery clock movements

  171. Pingback: clock mechanisms

  172. Pingback: large building contractors

  173. Pingback: steel church buildings

  174. Pingback: design build firms

  175. Pingback: tenant improvements construction

  176. Pingback: browse these web-site

  177. Pingback: erectors

  178. Pingback: industrial construction services

  179. Pingback: metal building erection

  180. Pingback: metal church buildings

  181. Pingback: where to buy quartz clock movements

  182. Pingback: prefabricated metal buildings

  183. Pingback: Industrial Contractors

  184. Pingback: general contractor

  185. Pingback: diy clock kit

  186. Pingback: industrial construction services

  187. Pingback: check the post right now

  188. Pingback: clock movement kit

  189. Pingback: facility construction

  190. Pingback: contractor

  191. Pingback: clockpart

  192. Pingback: tenant improvements construction

  193. Pingback: metal building erectors

  194. Pingback: building erectors

  195. Pingback: clock building kit

  196. Pingback: building contractor California

  197. Pingback: Construction Management

  198. Pingback: wholesale clock movement kits

  199. Pingback: metal building erectors

  200. Pingback: design build firms

  201. Pingback: clock parts for crafts

  202. Pingback: clock part

  203. Pingback: clock parts

  204. Pingback: Large wall clock kits

  205. Pingback: school clock and bell systems

  206. Pingback: click the following post

  207. Pingback: wireless clock system

  208. Pingback: click the following post

  209. Pingback: school pa systems

  210. Pingback: clock mechanism kit

  211. Pingback: replacement quartz clock movements

  212. Pingback: replacement parts for battery operated clocks

  213. Pingback: clock kits

  214. Pingback: wireless buzzer system suppliers

  215. Pingback: synchronized clocks for schools

  216. Pingback: wireless public address system

  217. Pingback: school clock and bell systems

  218. Pingback: clock parts

  219. Pingback: synchronized clocks

  220. Pingback: school pa system

  221. Pingback: clock parts

  222. Pingback: school public address system

  223. Pingback: school public address system

  224. Pingback: click the internet page

  225. Pingback: clock hardware

  226. Pingback: click over here

  227. Pingback: innovation wireless

  228. Pingback: where to buy quartz clock movements

  229. Pingback: pa system for school

  230. Pingback: wireless buzzer system for classroom

  231. Pingback: missoula plumber

  232. Pingback: Missoula boiler

  233. Pingback: synchronized clocks for schools

  234. Pingback: missoula plumbers

  235. Pingback: Axil Plumbing

  236. Pingback: View All

  237. Pingback: wireless pa speakers

  238. Pingback: school bell systems

  239. Pingback: school pa system

  240. Pingback: furnace repair missoula

  241. Pingback: wireless public address system

  242. Pingback: thomas plumbing and heating missoula

  243. Pingback: air quality mechanical missoula mt

  244. Pingback: school pa systems

  245. Pingback: heating and cooling missoula

  246. Pingback: wireless clock system

  247. Pingback: missoula hvac supply

  248. Pingback: school pa system

  249. Pingback: heating and cooling missoula

  250. Pingback: Missoula boiler

  251. Pingback: School bell system

  252. Pingback: plumbing missoula mt

  253. Pingback: wireless buzzer alarm

  254. Pingback: Axil Plumbing, Heating & Air

  255. Pingback: flymaster gps

  256. Pingback: missoula hvac supply

  257. Pingback: plumbers missoula

  258. Pingback: hvac contractor missoula mt

  259. Pingback: Click Here

  260. Pingback: anderson heating missoula

  261. Pingback: hvac Missoula MT

  262. Pingback: reserve parachute packing

  263. Pingback: concertina bag

  264. Pingback: anderson heating missoula

  265. Pingback: Fly Life Paragliding

  266. Pingback: air quality mechanical missoula, mt

  267. Pingback: plumbing missoula mt

  268. Pingback: temp right missoula

  269. Pingback: Sensbox

  270. Pingback: air conditioning repair missoula mt

  271. Pingback: graybeal heating missoula

  272. Pingback: reserve parachute packing

  273. Pingback: flytec 6005

  274. Pingback: flytec 6015

  275. Pingback: flymaster gps

  276. Pingback: mechanism for clocks

  277. Pingback: Skyman

  278. Pingback: Aroma Sense Essential Oils

  279. Pingback: best hands for clocks

  280. Pingback: best motor for clocks

  281. Pingback: metal clock dials

  282. Pingback: best motor for clocks

  283. Pingback: clock repair videos

  284. Pingback: large clock hands

  285. Pingback: replacement parts for clocks

  286. Pingback: best hands for clocks

  287. Pingback: DIY clock replacement parts

  288. Pingback: clock inserts suppliers

  289. Pingback: DIY clock replacement parts

  290. Pingback: mechanism for clocks

  291. Pingback: mechanism for clocks

  292. Pingback: clock making replacement parts

  293. Pingback: DIY clock dials repair

  294. Pingback: best motor for clocks

  295. Pingback: metal building erector

  296. Pingback: design steel buildings

  297. Pingback: metal building erector

  298. Pingback: prefab metal buildings

  299. Pingback: metal building construction

  300. Pingback: steel building suppliers

  301. Pingback: Enviromental construction

  302. Pingback: California construction company

  303. Pingback: clock manufacture

  304. Pingback: best steel building contractor

  305. Pingback: click Here

  306. Pingback: clock repair videos

  307. Pingback: time movement hands

  308. Pingback: metal building construction

  309. Pingback: how to replace clock dials

  310. Pingback: click the web page

  311. Pingback: clock mechanisms

  312. Pingback: metal clock dials

  313. Pingback: design metal buildings

  314. Pingback: USA Made clock movements

  315. Pingback: wireless public address system

  316. Pingback: how to build your own clock

  317. Pingback: Big clock parts

  318. Pingback: design builder construction

  319. Pingback: Clock repair parts

  320. Pingback: wireless buzzer system suppliers

  321. Pingback: PA systems

  322. Pingback: mechanism for clocks

  323. Pingback: click now

  324. Pingback: clock repair videos

  325. Pingback: metal building fabricator

  326. Pingback: Clock kits and dials

  327. Pingback: Click on %url_domain%

  328. Pingback: clocks for businesses

  329. Pingback: DIY clock replacement parts

  330. Pingback: innovation wireless

  331. Pingback: clock inserts suppliers

  332. Pingback: design steel buildings

  333. Pingback: get more info here

  334. Pingback: best motor for clocks

  335. Pingback: FCC wireless license

  336. Pingback: mechanisms for clocks

  337. Pingback: metal hands

  338. Pingback: best antique clock dials

  339. Pingback: metal clock dials

  340. Pingback: Click On this site

  341. Pingback: clock making replacement parts

  342. Pingback: DIY clock dials repair

  343. Pingback: PA systems for schools

  344. Pingback: best antique clock dials

Lascia un commento

Il tuo indirizzo email non sarà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *